Last updated: October 2026
DriveLedger vs a spreadsheet
A spreadsheet is free, works offline, and for one car that you alone maintain, it is genuinely enough. It stops being enough at three points: when you need the documents rather than the dates, when someone other than you needs access, and when the car is sold. DriveLedger holds the invoice and the job card, not just a row saying you had a service.
Most people who move to an app start from a spreadsheet. That is a reasonable place to start.
Where a spreadsheet wins
- It costs nothing. No subscription, no account, no upload.
- You already know how to use it. Columns for date, mileage, item, cost and notes take four minutes to set up.
- It is yours. No company can change it, charge for it, or shut it down.
- It handles arithmetic. Running cost per kilometre, service intervals, annual spend. A spreadsheet does this well and an app rarely does it better.
For a single vehicle, maintained by one person, in a household that keeps paperwork in a folder, this is a working system. Nobody should be talked out of it.
Where it stops
The row is not the document. "12 Mar 2024, 84,000 km, major service, R4,800" tells an assessor or a buyer almost nothing. What was replaced, which workshop, which parts, what warranty applies, whether the cambelt was done, what the invoice number was. The evidence lives in the invoice, and a spreadsheet cannot hold it.
It depends on one person. The file sits on one laptop or one drive account. If the owner is travelling, has left the business, or the laptop is stolen, the record is gone. Fleet operations feel this hardest: the history is trapped in whoever built the sheet.
It decays quietly. A column that stops being filled looks the same as a column that was never needed. Nobody notices the gap until the moment the record is being examined.
It does not travel. When the car is sold, the buyer does not get your spreadsheet. The record that should have raised the price stays with you, and the price does not move.
Nobody else can add to it. A spouse, a driver, a workshop, an accountant. A spreadsheet in one person's cloud account is a single-user record pretending to be a system.
Where DriveLedger wins
- The document is the entry. Photograph the invoice; the entry holds the image, the date, the mileage, the workshop and the amount. When someone asks what was done, the answer is a document rather than a typed claim.
- Access is shared, not transferred. Everyone who needs the history can be given access without handing over the master file.
- It survives the person who built it. The record belongs to the vehicle, not to an employee's laptop.
- It transfers at sale. The buyer receives the history in a link rather than a promise.
- It prompts. Service and licence reminders sit on the vehicle instead of in someone's memory.
The honest limitation
A spreadsheet still wins on one thing: it needs no discipline beyond typing a row. DriveLedger needs a photograph at the counter, taken at the moment the work is done. Skip that and the record degrades to the same incomplete summary you had before.
If you will not photograph invoices, a spreadsheet is the more truthful choice, because at least it will not imply evidence it does not have.
Which to choose
- One car, one owner, documents already in a folder: stay with the spreadsheet, or use the folder itself. Neither is a problem until proof is required.
- Multiple vehicles, or more than one person involved: the spreadsheet becomes a single point of failure. That is the point where the trapped-record problem starts costing money.
- Approaching a sale, a claim or a warranty dispute: the spreadsheet cannot help, because the question being asked is documentary.
For what a stamped book actually proves alongside either option, see DriveLedger vs a service book. For building a mileage trail that backs up every entry, see how to prove a car's mileage.
Frequently asked questions
Can I import my spreadsheet into DriveLedger?
Yes. Bringing the existing rows across gives the record a start date rather than beginning at zero.
Is a spreadsheet acceptable as proof of maintenance?
It is evidence of your own record-keeping, not of the work. An assessor or buyer will want the invoices, and the spreadsheet only tells them what to look for.
Do I still need a spreadsheet alongside DriveLedger?
No, and running both is how records become unreliable. Keep one.
What about a shared drive or a notes app?
Same trade-off as a spreadsheet: it holds text, not the documents, and access is all-or-nothing.
Information current as at October 2026.